Air Source vs Ground Source Heat Pump: Choosing the Best Option

Choosing between air source and ground source heat pumps can be challenging.

In this article, we will discuss “air source vs ground source” heat pumps by directly comparing their efficiency, installation process, costs, and suitability for different climates.

Get a heat pump quote now or read on to discover which type of heat pump best fits your home and heating needs.

Overview

• Ground source heat pumps offer higher efficiency and more stable performance in colder climates compared to air source heat pumps, but they come with higher installation costs and space requirements.
• Air source heat pumps are cheaper and easier to install, making them suitable for urban areas and homes with limited space, although their efficiency can drop in colder temperatures.
• Both types of heat pumps benefit from financial incentives such as government grants, which can significantly offset the initial installation costs and promote the adoption of renewable energy heating systems.

Heat Pumps: How do they work?

Entering the world of heat pumps, one encounters an environment where efficiency is paramount.

A heat pump is a marvel of renewable energy that captures the essence of warmth from the world around us—be it the air, ground, or water—and channels it into your abode to heat water and provide comforting warmth.

A heat pump, fundamentally, is made up of a compressor and a heat exchanger that work in tandem to circulate refrigerant through the system and extract heat from the aforementioned natural sources.

This ingenious process moves heat rather than generating it, which is why heat pumps can achieve a staggering coefficient of performance (COP) of around four.

In simpler terms, for every unit of electricity they consume, they can pump up to four units of heat into your home.

Heat pumps are multifunctional, capable of disseminating heat through diverse mediums like a central heating system, including:

• forced air
• hydronic systems
• radiators
• under-floor heating

They even play a role in providing sanitary hot water, making them a comprehensive solution for your home’s heating requirements.

Whether it’s an air source heat pump absorbing warmth from the chilly outside air, a ground source heat pump drawing upon the stable heat energy underground, or a gas boiler, heat pumps offer an efficient alternative to conventional heating systems.

Air Source vs Ground Source Heat Pumps: Key Differences

When we delve into the contrasts between air source and ground source heat pumps, we see a tapestry of differences that can influence your choice.

Ground source heat pumps, also known as geothermal heat pumps, have the following advantages:

• They bask in the consistent temperatures of the earth, usually around 10-12°C throughout the year.
• This stability translates into a higher efficiency rating under SAP of 320%, compared to the 250% for air source heat pumps in MCS installations.
• The ground source units have a source temperature that can be up to 15°C warmer than the cold air entering an air source unit, which can vary considerably from -5°C to 25°C over the seasons.

Conversely, air source heat pumps are lauded for their reduced initial installation expenses and flexibility.

They require less space and are less complex to install than their ground source counterparts.

However, this cost-effectiveness comes with a caveat; their efficiency can diminish in winter when the air temperature drops, potentially leading to higher running costs.

This is the main difference that swings the balance in favour of ground source heat pumps, which provide more stable temperatures and thus maintain higher efficiency throughout the year.

Ultimately, the choice between an air source vs ground source heat pumps hinges on several factors, including the available space and individual heating requirements.

While air source heat pumps are generally less expensive up front, it’s important to weigh the long-term implications of efficiency and running costs when making your decision.

Installation Process

Venturing into the installation process of heat pumps unveils a stark contrast between the two types.

The installation of a ground source heat pump is an intricate affair, requiring specialist subcontractors to navigate the complexities of digging trenches or drilling boreholes.

This labour-intensive work demands substantial outdoor space and can push the installation costs in the UK to fall between £16,200 and £49,000, depending on whether you’re laying horizontal pipes or drilling vertical boreholes.

Conversely, the installation of an air source heat pump is a more straightforward proposition, with air source heat pump costs ranging from £2,400 to £14,050. They are typically easier to install, demand less interior space, and are generally more affordable than ground source systems.

While air source heat pumps appeal to those with more modest budgets or limited outdoor space, they often require planning permission due to their noise output.

Ground source heat pumps, however, are visually unobtrusive once installed, usually not requiring planning permission, and are known for their quiet operation.

It’s clear then that if space and budget allow, a ground source heat pump is a robust choice for a long-term investment, while an air source heat pump proves to be a more flexible and accessible option for many homeowners, especially in high-density living areas where outdoor space is at a premium.

Efficiency in Different Climates

Heat pump efficiency is not a static metric, it fluctuates in accordance with the surrounding climate.

In the battle against cold winter temperatures, ground source heat pumps wield a significant advantage.

The warmth they extract from the earth is unaffected by the chill in the air, providing a constant source temperature that is often warmer than the very cold air temperatures faced by air source heat pumps.

This consistent underground warmth means ground source heat pumps can maintain higher efficiency even when the mercury plummets, reducing electricity consumption and carbon emissions.

Air source heat pumps, while highly energy-efficient in moderate climates, find themselves at a disadvantage in extreme cold.

Their efficiency can be compromised when temperatures drop, requiring more electricity to maintain heat output.

Yet, advancements in technology have enabled some models to continue working efficiently in temperatures as low as -15°C, demonstrating how heat pumps work even in challenging conditions.

The crux of the matter is that a ground source heat pump system is a formidable ally against the fiercest of winters, offering steadfast warmth and energy savings.

On the other hand, an air source heat pump system can be an optimal choice in milder climates, where it can perform with grace and efficiency.

Running Costs and Maintenance

Once the initial barrier of installation costs is overcome, the spotlight shifts to the ongoing operational costs and maintenance of heat pumps.

Ground source heat pumps, while bearing a higher upfront cost, can offer homeowners significant savings over the long haul due to their superior efficiency and longevity.

Their ground arrays, buried and out of sight, could last over a century with minimal maintenance.

In contrast, the running costs for air source heat pumps in the UK can range from £685 to £1,550 annually, influenced by the size of your home and your specific energy needs.

When it comes to maintenance, both types of heat pumps require attention, albeit at a modest rate.

Annual maintenance costs typically range from £100 to £200, with air source heat pumps recommended to receive an annual service.

Ground source heat pumps, on the other hand, are relatively low maintenance but do require regular checks and servicing to ensure optimal performance.

Reflecting on these costs, it becomes evident that while air source heat pumps may have higher running costs than ground source pumps, their typically cheaper upfront price and very little maintenance requirements make them an appealing choice for those eyeing a balance between initial investment and long-term savings.

Space and Location Requirements

Choosing between an air source and a ground source heat pump is often dictated by the pragmatic concern of space availability.

For ground source heat pumps, ample outdoor space is non-negotiable due to the extensive groundwork needed for laying horizontal loops or drilling boreholes.

This can make them less suitable for urban properties with limited plots. Air source heat pumps, in stark contrast, require far less outdoor space for the pump unit, though they do have specific requirements for space around them to ensure proper airflow and noise control.

Location plays a pivotal role as well. Coastal areas can be detrimental to the longevity of an air source heat pump due to saltwater corrosion on internal components.

Ground source heat pumps are less susceptible to external environmental factors, as their primary components are shielded underground.

These space and location considerations are crucial when contemplating the suitability of a heat pump.

While ground source heat pumps may be ideal for rural or spacious suburban properties, air source heat pumps offer a more compact and versatile solution for urban dwellers or those with smaller outdoor areas.

Heating and Hot Water Output

The ultimate aim of both air source and ground source heat pump systems is to ensure a cosy living environment and provide a dependable hot water supply. Air source heat pumps are particularly adept at this, able to generate up to three times the heat energy for every unit of electricity consumed.

They are compatible with various heating methods, including underfloor heating and traditional radiators, although it’s worth noting that radiators may need to be larger than usual to effectively distribute the lower heat output of a heat pump.

Ground source heat pumps, with their ability to heat water up to about 50°C, are also an excellent match for underfloor heating systems, which thrive on lower temperatures.

The consistent temperature underground ensures a steady and efficient heat output, making ground source heat pumps a reliable source of warmth and hot water throughout the year.

Environmental Impact

In contemporary times, the environmental impact of your heating system carries significant importance. Ground source heat pumps emerge as champions in this arena, capable of:

• Reducing a home’s carbon emissions by up to 90%
• Harnessing the stable temperature underground
• Offering a highly energy-efficient solution
• Running during low-demand electricity periods, making the most of low-carbon energy sources

This remarkable efficiency under SAP of 320% positions ground source heat pumps as the lowest carbon heating system available.

Air source heat pumps also contribute to lowering carbon emissions, albeit to a lesser extent, offering a reduction of up to 20% compared to traditional heating systems.

While not as impactful as ground source pumps, air source heat pumps still represent a significant step towards a more sustainable future, especially when compared to fossil fuel-based systems.

The choice between air source and ground source heat pumps, therefore, extends beyond personal comfort to encompass the broader implications of environmental stewardship.

By opting for a heat pump, you are aligning with a vision of a greener world, with ground source heat pumps leading the charge in maximizing energy efficiency and minimizing carbon emissions.

Cost and Financial Incentives

Navigating the financial landscape of heat pump installation can be eased by the presence of government grants and subsidies.

These incentives can help bridge the gap between the higher installation costs of ground source heat pumps, which typically range from £13,200 to £19,000, and the more affordable air source heat pumps, which can cost between £8,750 to £14,050.

The Boiler Upgrade Scheme, for instance, offers savings of up to £7,500 for both types of heat pumps, making them more accessible to homeowners.

These facilitative measures underscore the commitment to transitioning to renewable energy heating systems and can significantly alleviate the upfront financial burden.

With grants and subsidies available, the long-term savings in running costs coupled with the environmental benefits make heat pumps an increasingly viable and attractive option for homeowners looking to invest in a renewable energy heating system.

Taking advantage of these financial incentives allows homeowners to:

• Reap the benefits of the exceptional efficiency of heat pumps
• Play their part in the worldwide endeavor to cut down on fossil fuel dependency and reduce carbon emissions
• Take a step towards future-proofing their home against escalating energy prices and the impending challenges of climate change.

Choosing the Right Heat Pump for Your Home

The quest to choose the ideal heat pump for your home is a personal and complex process. It involves a careful assessment of:

• your available space
• the unique specifications of your property
• the degree of insulation
• your specific heating requirements.

Air source heat pumps shine in scenarios where retrofitting is the goal, especially in existing buildings where installation space might be limited.

They are also a more cost-effective solution for those with tighter budgets or smaller plots of land.

Ground source heat pumps, on the other hand, are the paragons of efficiency and stability, ideal for new constructions where the necessary groundwork can be incorporated into the initial design.

Their longevity and low maintenance needs, coupled with their unrivaled efficiency in colder climates, make them a wise choice for those able to invest upfront for long-term gains.

Ultimately, the decision rests with you, the homeowner. By considering the full spectrum of factors—from the initial cost to the long-term environmental and financial benefits—you can choose a heat pump that aligns with your values, meets your needs, and secures a comfortable and sustainable home for years to come.

Summary

In summary, the decision between air source and ground source heat pumps is nuanced, dependent on a blend of factors including installation complexity, climate efficiency, running costs, space requirements, environmental impact, and financial considerations.

Ground source heat pumps stand out for their unparalleled efficiency and environmental benefits, while air source heat pumps offer greater flexibility and lower upfront costs.

By carefully weighing these elements, you can choose a heat pump that not only provides comfort and savings but also aligns with your commitment to a greener future.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is best, an air source or ground source heat pump?

If you live in an area with very cold winter temperatures, a ground source heat pump may be more efficient over the year. Whether it’s the best option for you will depend on factors such as ground temperature and expected air temperatures.

How much more efficient is a ground source heat pump compared to an air source heat pump?

Ground source heat pumps are significantly more efficient than air source heat pumps, with a higher efficiency rating of 320% compared to the default value of 250% for air source heat pumps.

Do I need planning permission to install a heat pump?

In most cases, ground source heat pumps do not require planning permission, as they are not visually obtrusive. However, air source heat pumps typically require planning permission due to their noise output.

Can heat pumps provide hot water as well as heating?

Yes, both air source and ground source heat pumps can provide hot water for use in your home, with ground source heat pumps capable of heating water up to about 50°C.

What are the running costs for air source and ground source heat pumps?

Ground source heat pumps offer lower running costs compared to air source heat pumps due to their higher efficiency.